1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
|
<HTML>
<BODY>
<H1 ALIGN="RIGHT"><A NAME="INTRO">1 - Introduction to EPM</A></H1>
<P>This chapter provides an introduction to the ESP Package Manager ("EPM").
<H2>What is EPM?</H2>
<P>Software distribution under UNIX/Linux can be a challenge,
especially if you ship software for more than one operating
system. Every operating system provides its own software
packaging tools and each has unique requirements or implications
for the software development environment.</P>
<P>The ESP Package Manager ("EPM") is one solution to this
problem. Besides its own "portable" distribution format, EPM
also supports the generation of several vendor-specific formats.
This allows you to build software distribution files for almost
any operating system from the same sources.</P>
<H2>History and Evolution</H2>
<P>When Easy Software Products was founded in 1993, we
originally shipped software only for the SGI IRIX operating
system. In 1997 we added support for Solaris, which was quickly
followed by HP-UX support in 1998.</P>
<P>Each new operating system and supported processor required a
new set of packaging files. While this worked, it also meant
that we had to keep all of the packaging files synchronized
manually. Needless to say, this process was far from perfect and
we had more than one distribution that was not identical on all
operating systems.</P>
<P>As we began developing CUPS
(<A HREF="http://www.cups.org/">http://www.cups.org/</A>) in
1997, our initial goal was to add support for two additional
operating systems: Linux and Compaq Tru64 UNIX. If we wanted to
avoid the mistakes of the past, we clearly had to change how we
produced software distributions.</P>
<P>The first version of EPM was released in 1999 and supported
so-called "portable" software distributions that were not tied
to any particular operating system or packaging software. Due to
popular demand, we added support for vendor-specific packaging
formats in the second major release of EPM, allowing the
generation of portable or "native" distributions from one
program and one set of software distribution files.
<H2>Existing Software Packaging Systems</H2>
<P>As we looked for a solution to our problem, we naturally
investigated the existing open-source packaging systems. Under
Linux, we looked at the Red Hat Package Manager ("RPM") and
Debian packaging software ("dpkg" and "dselect"). For the
commercial UNIX's we looked at the vendor-supplied packaging
systems. <A HREF="#TABLE_1_1">Table 1.1</A> shows the results of
our investigation.</P>
<!-- NEED 5in -->
<TABLE ALIGN="CENTER" BORDER="1">
<CAPTION><A NAME="TABLE_1_1">Table 1.1: Software Packaging Formats</A></CAPTION>
<TR>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Format</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Operating Systems<SUP>1</SUP></FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Binaries</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Cross- Platform</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Patches</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Up- grades</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Con- flicts</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Re- quires</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Re- places</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Config Files</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Map Files</FONT></TH>
<TH><FONT SIZE="-4">Un- install</FONT></TH>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>installp</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>AIX</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>pkg_add</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>FreeBSD</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes<SUP>2</SUP></SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>pkg_add</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>NetBSD<BR>
OpenBSD</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes<SUP>2</SUP></SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>dpkg</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Corel Linux<BR>
Debian GNU/Linux</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes<SUP>2</SUP></SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>depot</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>HP-UX</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>inst</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>IRIX</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Install.app</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>MacOS X</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>pkgadd</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Solaris</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>rpm</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Mandrake<BR>
Red Hat<BR>
SuSE<BR>
TurboLinux</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes<SUP>2</SUP></SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>setld</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Tru64 UNIX</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
<TR>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>slackware</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Slackware Linux</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>No</SMALL></TD>
<TD ALIGN="CENTER"><SMALL>Yes</SMALL></TD>
</TR>
</TABLE>
<OL>
<LI>Standard packaging system for named operating systems.</LI>
<LI>These packaging systems are cross-platform but require
the package management utilities to be installed on the
platform before installing the package.</LI>
</OL>
<P> </P>
<P>As you can see, none of the formats supported every feature we
were looking for. One common fault of all these formats is that
they do not support a common software specification file format.
That is, making a Debian software distribution requires
significantly different support files than required for a Solaris
pkg distribution. This makes it extremely difficult to manage
distributions for multiple operating systems.</P>
<P>All of the package formats support binary distributions. The
RPM and Debian formats also support source distributions that
specifically allow for recompilation and installation. Only the
commercial UNIX formats support patch distributions - you have
to completely upgrade a software package with RPM and Debian.
All but the Solaris <CODE>pkg</CODE> format allow you to upgrade
a package without removing the old version first.</P>
<P>When building the software packages, RPM and Debian force you
to create the actual directories, copy the files to those
directories, and set the ownerships and permissions. You
essentially are creating a directory for your software that can
be archived in the corresponding package format. To ensure that
all file permissions and ownerships are correct, you must build
the distribution as the root user or use the
<CODE>fakeroot</CODE> software, introducing potential security
risks and violating many corporate security policies. It can also
make building distributions difficult when dynamic data such as
changing data files or databases is involved.</P>
<P>The commercial UNIX formats use software list files that map
source files to the correct directories and permissions.
This allows for easier delivery of dynamic data, configuration
management of what each distribution actually contains, and
eliminates security issues with special permissions and building
distributions as the root user. Using the proprietary format
also has the added benefit of allowing for software patches and
using the familiar software installation tools for that
operating system. The primary disadvantage is that the same
distributions and packaging software cannot be used on other
operating systems.</P>
<H2>Design Goals of EPM</H2>
<P>EPM was designed from the beginning to build binary software
distributions using a common software specification format. The
same distribution files work for all operating systems and all
distribution formats. Supporting source code distributions was
not a goal since most RPM and Debian source distributions are
little more than wrapping around a compressed tar file
containing the source files and a configure script.</P>
<P>Over the years, additional features have made their way into
EPM to support more advanced software packages. Whenever
possible, EPM emulates a feature if the vendor package format
does not support it natively.</P>
<H2>Resources</H2>
<P>The EPM web site provides access to the current software, documentation,
and discussion forums for EPM:</P>
<PRE>
<A HREF="http://www.epmhome.org/">http://www.epmhome.org/</A>
</PRE>
<P>The EPM source code can be downloaded in compressed tar files or
via the popular Subversion software. Please see the EPM web site for
complete instructions.</P>
<P>Send book feedback to
"<A HREF="mailto:epm-book@easysw.com">epm-book@easysw.com</A>".</P>
</BODY>
</HTML>
|
